 |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
 |
 |
| Police secure the Polish constitutional court in Warsaw while demonstrations take place outside. (© picture-alliance/NurPhoto / Artur Widak) |
 |
 | |
The long-running power struggle over Poland's constitutional court has escalated. Donald Tusk's government wants to reform the court, which was politically influenced by the PiS for years. However, President Karol Nawrocki, who has close ties to the PiS, is blocking the swearing-in of new judges. PiS supporters demonstrated outside the constitutional court in Warsaw at the weekend, and there were also disturbances inside the building. |
 |
|
|  | | |
| Violence instead of justicePolityka criticises the head of state: “President Nawrocki has apparently decided to escalate the conflict. To what end? Having forced his way into the constitutional court, it seems his sole aim was to impose his will: I have decided to prevent five judges elected by this Sejm from carrying out their duties, and I will ensure that this is the case. This is not the rule of law; this is violence. One could argue that Judge Korwin-Piotrowska misinterpreted and misapplied the legal provision which allows for the exclusion of another judge whose actions could prejudice the administration of justice. There are some legal doubts. But this is a legal measure, not an act of violence.”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
| | |
|
| | |
|
|  | | |
| Government betraying its own idealsPaweł Kapusta, editor-in-chief of Rzeczpospolita, voices his disappointment with Tusk’s government: “Donald Tusk stood for election alongside the entire coalition under the banner of redress, the rule of law and inviolable principles. ... They were convinced that the restoration of the rule of law would take place swiftly and with dignity. ... Today, however, we hear from those in power that there is 'no alternative' – a trite phrase that can be used to justify all courses of action. Batons, police cordons outside the constitutional court, people entering the building under cover of night, exploiting loopholes in the law, and the fact that the president is abroad – none of this is evidence of decisiveness and strength, but rather an expression of helplessness.”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
| | |
|
| | |
|
|  | | |
| Fear of losing immunityThe conflict has been smouldering for years, explains La Repubblica: “When Donald Tusk won the elections in 2023, he promised to restore the independence of the judiciary and the democratic separation of powers, but he found himself having to contend with two Presidents of the Republic from the ranks of the PiS – Andrzej Duda and Karol Nawrocki – who wield enormous veto powers and have attempted to thwart his plans in every conceivable way. The loss of a majority in the constitutional court and the Supreme Court would also mean the loss of immunity for many PiS representatives. This applies in particular to the President of the constitutional court himself, Bogdan Święczkowski, who faces four pending criminal proceedings.”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
| | |
|
| | |
|
|  | | |
| Tusk not aiming for judicial independenceFor Prime Minister Tusk, this is not about the independence of the constitutional court, writes Interia: “In his speech, Tusk spoke out against a constitutional reset. In his view, PiS has 'stolen' the constitutional court, so he is not planning to share what has been stolen with them. Rather, he wants to reclaim it in its entirety. Does this mean in practice that eight judges (out of the required fifteen) will form a 'renewed' constitutional court? These people, although portrayed as independent, behave like an army's disciplinary unit carrying out government orders. ... Tusk prefers to take over the existing system and use it for his own purposes.”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
| | |
|
| | |
|
|  | | |
| No victory for the constitutional stateIn any case, this does not serve the rule of law, argues Gazeta Wyborcza: “You may well ask: But what else could have been done? This can be answered with a counter-question: What, in fact, has been gained by these actions? A new, weakened constitutional court, should it continue to exist, will have no authority – just as it had none before. Only Tusk's government will recognise its rulings. ... So, just as under the PiS, we will have a constitutional court that examines motions only from a single party – namely, the one currently in power. Yet the constitutional court is supposed to be an instrument of the opposition, which challenges the laws passed by the majority.”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
| | |
|
| | |
|
|  | | |
| Rules must apply regardless of who is in powerPolitical analyst Alexandru Grumaz writes in Adevărul: “Breaking the deadlock will take more than simply filling the post of President of the Court. Everything should be clarified separately: the status of the elected judges, a valid swearing-in procedure, grounds for suspensions, and who, if anyone, bears individual responsibility. … A constitutional court loses its significance if each party only recognises it on days when it rules in their favour. And the restoration of its authority is not measured by the satisfaction of a majority but by the fact that the rules remain valid even after a change in political power.”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
| | |
|
|
 |
 | | Share on | |  | |  | |
|
 |
 |
 | |
At the weekend, thousands of people – mostly young – took to the streets again in several European countries to demonstrate for better education, more participation and affordable living standards. After peaceful demonstrations, the protests turned violent in a number of German and French cities. Commentators analyse the anger and its causes. |
 |
|
|  | | |
| Harsher timesThe riots don't make the young people's anger any less legitimate, argues taz: “In many cases, the burning rubbish bins may even have been a consequence of this debate on violence – a defiant attempt to show that they will not be told how to demonstrate. ... It's good that we are now seeing at least the beginnings of an emancipatory counter-movement against the feeling of hopelessness. ... These are harsher times and it's clear that only a few sections of the media and political establishment will take a positive view of the movement. A look at the rest of the world shows that 'Gen Z rules' can nevertheless still achieve something. To do so, however, the movement must build up pressure – and not allow itself to be divided.”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
| | |
|
| | |
|
|  | | |
| Against freedom in the name of freedomThe protests pose a risk to the freedom of the majority, warns Le Figaro: “From day one, this student movement has confused the right to demonstrate with a desire for destruction. … For many schoolchildren, university students and teachers, the freedom to learn and teach is already no more than a distant memory. Extremely small minority groups are obstructing, intimidating and threatening a large majority of young people who want to use these crucial weeks to learn, think for themselves and live their lives independently. Freedom of expression is also under attack from all sides. ... No freedom for the enemies of Insoumis [the LFI party]': that is the principle Jean-Luc Mélenchon aims to enforce even before the presidential election takes place. All democrats must stand up against this.”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
| | |
|
| | |
|
|  | | |
| Historical point of referenceThis could be the start of a larger movement much like that of May 1968, says France Inter: “Although none of these movements are identical, they undoubtedly have one thing in common. They are driven by generational anger. Young people accuse the older generations of having exploited the system while leaving them with a bleak future – and even a broken society. This brings to mind the Fridays for Future in 2019 led by Greta Thunberg, or the Indignados movement against [Spain's] austerity measures in 2011. But the major historical point of reference is May 1968. ... What is happening now is perhaps reminiscent of that famous spring, even though it was a different era and took place almost 60 years ago.”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
| | |
|
| | |
|
|  | | |
| Golden opportunity for Portugal’s leftFollowing the police clearance of protest camps in Porto and Lisbon, Expresso comments: “Police violence has shaken up the entire left, which had been lost, demotivated and demoralised, but has now finally found a cause with which many people can identify. For years, it wasted its time on cultural and identity struggles which, while mobilising minorities, alienated a key section of the wider population. The issue of housing is precisely the opposite. It is an economic, social and cross-generational issue that affects all classes and voter groups alike. … Police violence and the government's arrogance have driven people onto the streets in droves.”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
| | |
|
|
 |
 | | Share on | |  | |  | |
|
 |
 |
 | |
According to projections, the incumbent Iliana Iotova has won the run-off election for the presidency in Bulgaria. With almost all votes counted, she has secured a clear victory over her pro-Western challenger, Andrey Gyurov. Iotova advocates dialogue with Russia and opposes military aid for Ukraine. |
 |
|
|  | | |
| Pro-Russian policy wins the dayCorriere della Sera comments: “The Bulgarians have decided to confirm the incumbent president, Iliana Iotova, in her post. Backed by Prime Minister Rumen Radev, she left her challenger, Andrey Gyurov – an economist supported by liberal pro-Europeans – trailing far behind. ... Iotova knows that the voters have chosen a complete package: herself, Radev and the current policy towards Moscow. ... Radev's patriotic rhetoric on foreign policy has translated into Eurosceptic and pro-Russian stances. These very same positions were also adopted by Iotova in this hard-fought election campaign: while Radev portrayed the election as a choice between 'peace and war', she presented herself as the 'President of Peace'.”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
| | |
|
| | |
|
|  | | |
| Divisive fear campaignIotowa has won votes primarily by stoking fears of war, criticises Fakti.bg: “In her campaign appearances, she has often emphasised that Gyurov 'will lead Bulgaria into a war'. In practice, this is not possible, as the Constitution stipulates that decisions such as this are to be taken exclusively by parliament. ... The exploitation of fear in election campaigns is a phenomenon observed worldwide. ... This campaign strategy is particularly problematic because it divides society. Claims like this automatically turn opponents into enemies, not only in political terms but also on a purely human level. And there is no discussion of the actual political issues.”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
|
 |
 | | Share on | |  | |  | |
|
 |
 |
 | |
The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) has cleared the way for Russian teams to participate in ice hockey championships again. The court upheld an appeal by the Russian Ice Hockey Federation and overturned the decision by the International Ice Hockey Federation (IIHF) to bar Russian teams, with immediate effect. What does this mean for the players, and for the World Championship due to take place in Germany in 2027? |
 |
|
|  | | |
| Sport and war do not go hand in handThe ruling undermines the spirit of sport, Novinky.cz protests: “Allowing a Russian team to participate in the championship gives the impression that it is acceptable to wage a war which Russia hypocritically refers to as a 'special military operation'. For even Moscow refuses to admit that it is waging a war of aggression. Sport does not exist in some ivory tower, far removed from the real world. Athletes don't live outside reality, as Ukrainian athletes know all too well. Russian bombs, drones and missiles kill them just like everyone else, and destroy their sports grounds. If Ukrainian athletes are paying the ultimate price for Russia's aggression, why should we make concessions to Moscow?”
| |
| | Share on | |  | |  | | |
 |
| | |
|
| | |
|
|  | | |
| Politics has the final sayIt won't happen quite that fast, writes ice hockey expert Klaus Zaugg in Watson: “In theory, the Russians should now be allowed to take part in the 2027 IIHF World Championship in Germany (13 to 30 May). But they won't be there in 2027. For several reasons. ... First, it's politics, not sport, that has the final say. ... Second, participation in the World Championship is only possible if the host country – in this case, Germany – issues entry visas for the players and support staff. ... There will be considerable political resistance in Germany to issuing these visas. No other European country is as strongly committed to Ukraine as Germany. ... Are the tickets already purchased for Ukraine's matches now supposed to be valid for Russia's matches? Absurd.”
| |
| |